When Owning a Rental Property Just Isn’t Fun Anymore

When you first bought your rental property, it may have sounded like a great investment.

Collect rent. Build equity. Let someone else help pay down the mortgage. Hold onto the property while it appreciates.

But somewhere along the way, being a landlord started feeling less like an investment and more like another job.

The phone calls.

The repairs.

The late rent.

The maintenance.

The property taxes.

Finding tenants.

Dealing with contractors.

Worrying about what is happening at the property when you are not there.

And maybe you have reached the point where you are thinking:

“I just don’t want to do this anymore.”

If you own one or more rental properties in Burlington County, Camden County or Gloucester County, New Jersey, you are not necessarily stuck being a landlord forever.

It may simply be time to find out what your property is worth and whether selling makes sense for the next chapter of your life.

Why South Jersey Landlords Decide to Sell

There isn't always one dramatic reason.

Sometimes you are simply tired.

Maybe you have owned the property for 10, 20 or 30 years and your priorities have changed.

You may be thinking:

• I'm getting older and don't want the stress anymore.

• I'm retiring and want to simplify my life.

• I'm moving out of New Jersey and don't want to manage a property from another state.

• I never realized being a landlord would require this much work.

• I'm tired of dealing with repairs and maintenance.

• My property needs updating and I don't want to put more money into it.

• I inherited a rental and don't really want to be a landlord.

• I'm tired of tenant turnover.

• I'd rather take the equity out of the property and use the money somewhere else.

• I simply don't enjoy being a landlord anymore.

Those are all valid reasons to at least explore your options.

A rental property may still be producing income and yet no longer fit your life.

That distinction matters.

Just because an investment has been good to you does not mean you have to own it forever.

“But I Have a Tenant. Can I Still Sell?”

This is one of the biggest concerns I hear from rental property owners.

The answer is that you may be able to sell your rental property while the tenant is still living there.

You do not necessarily have to wait until the property is vacant before putting it on the market.

According to the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs' Truth in Renting guidance, when a new landlord takes over a rental property, the new landlord and tenant must honor the existing rental agreement until it expires.

That means a tenant-occupied property can potentially be sold with the lease remaining in place.

And depending on the property, that may actually be attractive to another investor.

Instead of purchasing an empty property and then searching for a tenant, an investor may be buying a property that already has rental income coming in.

Every situation is different, however. The lease, tenant status, property type and applicable New Jersey landlord-tenant requirements should be reviewed before deciding how to market the property.

When legal questions are involved, I always recommend having your attorney review your specific situation.

How Do You Show a Rental Property When Someone Is Living There?

This is where planning matters.

Selling a tenant-occupied property needs to be handled differently than selling your own home.

You want to protect the tenant's rights and minimize unnecessary disruption while still giving qualified buyers an opportunity to see the property.

Depending on the situation, we can create a showing strategy that may include:

• Limiting showings to certain days or times

• Providing the appropriate notice before showings

• Grouping appointments together rather than having constant interruptions

• Marketing primarily toward investors

• Providing detailed property information before scheduling a showing

• Working around the tenant's schedule when possible

• Reviewing the lease before the property is listed

There is no reason to create unnecessary chaos.

A thoughtful marketing strategy should consider the landlord, the tenant and the potential buyer.

Your Tenant Could Actually Be an Advantage

Many landlords automatically assume:

“Nobody is going to want the house because there is a tenant.”

That isn't necessarily true.

For the right investor, an established tenant can be an advantage.

An investor considering the property may want to know:

• What is the monthly rent?

• How long has the tenant lived there?

• When does the lease expire?

• Is the tenant paying on time?

• Who pays the utilities?

• What expenses does the owner pay?

• What maintenance or improvements have been completed?

• What is the property's rental history?

• What is the property's potential rental income?

That information helps a potential investor determine whether your South Jersey rental property fits their investment goals.

The tenant is not always an obstacle to the sale.

Sometimes the existing lease and rental history are part of what makes the property appealing.

What If My Rental Property Needs Work?

Another reason landlords hesitate to sell is because they look around the property and think:

“I would have to spend a fortune fixing this before I could sell it.”

Not necessarily.

There is more than one way to sell a rental property, and the right approach depends on the condition of the home, your timeline and how involved you want to be.

Option 1: Prepare the Property and Sell Traditionally

If the property is vacant or can easily be prepared for the market, making strategic improvements may help you achieve a higher selling price.

But that does not mean renovating everything.

Sometimes cleaning, painting, repairing obvious problems and improving curb appeal are enough to make a meaningful difference.

The goal should be to determine which improvements are actually worth making before you spend the money.

Option 2: Sell the Property As-Is on the MLS

Maybe the last thing you want is another renovation project.

An as-is MLS sale may allow you to expose the property to a larger pool of buyers while making it clear that you do not intend to renovate the property before selling.

That does not mean ignoring disclosure requirements or other obligations. It simply means we build the marketing strategy around the property's current condition.

Option 3: Sell With the Tenant in Place

If there is an existing tenant and lease, the property may potentially be marketed specifically toward investors who are comfortable purchasing a tenant-occupied rental.

This can eliminate the need to wait for the property to become vacant before exploring a sale.

Option 4: Consider an Investor or Cash Sale

If convenience and speed are more important to you than testing the property on the broader market, an investor or cash sale may be another option.

The important thing is to compare your options before deciding.

I don't believe every landlord should automatically sell to an investor simply because a property needs work or has a tenant.

Sometimes an MLS sale may produce a better result.

Sometimes an investor sale may better fit the owner's priorities.

You should understand what each option could realistically mean for you before making that decision.

Before Selling Your South Jersey Rental Property

Before putting your rental property on the market, it helps to gather some basic information.

That may include:

• Current lease

• Monthly rent

• Security deposit information

• Utility responsibilities

• Property tax information

• Recent repair and maintenance records

• Certificates or registrations that apply to the property

• Information about major improvements

• Mortgage balance, if applicable

From there, we can discuss the property's condition, tenant situation, likely buyer, potential selling price and the best way to bring it to market.

Your attorney and tax professional should also advise you about the legal and tax consequences of selling an investment property.

The goal is not to rush into listing.

The goal is to understand the entire picture first.

Selling a Rental Property in Burlington County

If you own a rental property in Mount Laurel, Marlton, Evesham, Maple Shade, Moorestown, Cinnaminson, Delran, Willingboro, Burlington, Hainesport, Mount Holly, Medford, Lumberton or another Burlington County community, your first step does not have to be putting a For Sale sign in the yard.

It can simply be finding out what the property may be worth and what your realistic selling options are.

You may discover that selling now makes sense.

You may decide to hold onto it longer.

Either way, having real numbers makes the decision easier.

Selling a Rental Property in Camden County

The same applies if you own an investment property in Cherry Hill, Pennsauken, Voorhees, Collingswood, Haddon Township, Haddon Heights, Barrington, Berlin, Merchantville or another Camden County community.

A tenant-occupied property, an older rental that needs updating and a vacant investment property may each require a completely different selling strategy.

There isn't one formula that works for every landlord or every property.

Selling a Rental Property in Gloucester County

Landlords in Williamstown, Washington Township, Glassboro, West Deptford, Deptford, National Park, Woolwich and throughout Gloucester County may also be sitting on significant equity after years of owning their investment properties.

At some point, the question becomes less about whether the property has been a good investment and more about whether continuing to own it still makes sense for you.

You Don't Have to Decide Today

Maybe you aren't completely sure you want to sell.

That's okay.

Before making that decision, you can start by answering a few questions:

What is my rental property worth today?

Could I sell it with my tenant still living there?

Would I make more selling it traditionally or as-is?

Would another investor want the property?

What should I fix before selling, and what should I leave alone?

How much work would selling actually require from me?

Those are questions we can answer before you commit to anything.

Sometimes simply knowing your options takes a lot of the stress out of the decision.

Frequently Asked Questions About Selling a Rental Property in New Jersey

Can I sell my New Jersey rental property with a tenant living in it?

Yes, a rental property can potentially be sold while it is tenant-occupied.

According to guidance from the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs, a new landlord and tenant generally must honor an existing rental agreement until it expires.

Your specific lease, tenant situation and other applicable landlord-tenant requirements should be reviewed before deciding how the property will be marketed.

Do I have to wait until my tenant's lease expires before selling?

Not necessarily.

The property may potentially be marketed and sold with the tenant and existing lease remaining in place.

Depending on the property, this could make it particularly relevant to investors looking for an income-producing rental.

Your lease and individual circumstances should still be reviewed before determining the best strategy.

Will investors buy tenant-occupied properties in South Jersey?

Yes, they can.

An occupied rental may appeal to an investor depending on factors such as the rent, lease terms, tenant history, property condition, location, expenses and overall investment potential.

For some buyers, having an established tenant and rental history may actually be appealing.

Do I have to renovate my rental property before selling it?

No.

You can compare several approaches, including making strategic improvements, selling the property as-is on the MLS, selling with the tenant in place or considering an investor sale.

Before spending money on renovations, I recommend finding out which improvements are actually likely to matter to the buyers you are targeting.

You may need to do much less than you think.

What happens to the security deposit if I sell my New Jersey rental property?

New Jersey has specific requirements involving security deposits when ownership of a rental property changes.

The New Jersey Department of Community Affairs explains that when a property is sold or transferred, the new owner becomes responsible for the required handling of the tenant's security deposit and accrued interest.

Because security deposits are regulated by New Jersey law, the transfer should be handled correctly as part of the sale. Your real estate attorney can advise you on the requirements that apply to your specific transaction.

What are the tax consequences of selling a rental property?

Selling an investment property can have different tax consequences than selling a primary residence.

Depending on your situation, the sale may involve capital gains and depreciation-related tax considerations. Your property's adjusted basis, improvements, depreciation history and how the property has been used can all matter.

Before making a decision, speak with your CPA or tax professional so you understand the potential tax consequences based on your individual circumstances.

Can you help me sell an investment property in Burlington, Camden or Gloucester County?

Yes.

I help South Jersey property owners evaluate their selling options and develop a strategy based on the property's condition, tenant situation, location and the owner's priorities.

That can include exploring a traditional MLS sale, an as-is sale, selling with a tenant in place or determining whether an investor-focused strategy makes more sense.

Tired of Being a Landlord in South Jersey? Let's Look at Your Options.

After 31 years in South Jersey real estate, I have worked with homeowners and investors through all kinds of transitions.

And sometimes selling isn't really about the property.

It's about getting your time back.

It's about retiring.

It's about simplifying.

It's about moving closer to family.

Or maybe you have simply reached the point where you don't want a tenant calling on Saturday morning because the water heater stopped working.

If you own a rental property in Burlington County, Camden County or Gloucester County and you're thinking, “Being a landlord is stressing me out,” you don't have to make a decision today.

Let's start with the questions that matter:

What could your property sell for today?

Can you sell it with the tenant still there?

Would it make more sense to sell as-is, prepare it for the market or market it to another investor?

Sometimes the right decision is to sell.

Sometimes it isn't.

My job is to help you understand what your options actually look like so you can make the decision that works for you.

Michaela L. Hartery
NJ Broker Associate
South Jersey Realtor and Real Estate Investor

CLICK TO FIND OUT WHAT YOUR RENTAL PROPERTY IS WORTH